Evaluation of Two ANN Approaches for the Wind Power Forecast in a Mountainous Site

matteo mana, Massimiliano Burlando, Catherine Meissner


Accurate wind power forecast is very important in order to construct smart electric grids. Nevertheless, this task still constitutes a challenge because wind is a very variable and local phenomenon. It is difficult to downscale information coming from Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) models down to wind farm level and this is especially true onshore, in complex terrain conditions. Artificial Intelligence often comes at hand, for its power in learning what is hidden inside data: Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) are therefore commonly employed for wind power forecast. In this work, a pure ANN method is compared against a hybrid method, based on the combination of ANN and a numerical method based on physically-consistent assumptions (Computational Fluid Dynamics). Both approaches are validated against the SCADA data of a wind farm sited in Italy in a very complex terrain. It arises that the two methods have overall similar performances on average. However, pure ANN turns out to forecast better at mid-energy levels and during cut-off events at the highest wind speed, whereas the hybrid method forecasts better during low and high wind speed ranges. This makes the two approaches complementary and promising for future applications through an ensemble strategy.

Total Views: 147


wind energy, power forecast, Computational Fluid Dynamics, Artificial Neural Network, SCADA control system

Full Text:



Xu, Z., Gordon, M., Lind, M., & Ostergaard, J. (2009, July). Towards a Danish power system with 50% wind—Smart grids activities in Denmark. In Power & Energy Society General Meeting, 2009. PES'09. IEEE (pp. 1-8). IEEE.

Vaca, S. M., Patsios, C., & Taylor, P. (2016, November). Enhancing frequency response of wind farms using hybrid energy storage systems. In Renewable Energy Research and Applications (ICRERA), 2016 IEEE International Conference on (pp. 325-329). IEEE.

Tazi, N., Châtelet, E., Meziane, R., & Bouzidi, Y. (2016, November). Reliability optimization of wind farms considering constraints and regulations. In Renewable Energy Research and Applications (ICRERA), 2016 IEEE International Conference on (pp. 130-136). IEEE.

Hashimoto, A., Kanougi, R., Hayasaki, N., Yamaguchi, A., Kajihara, F., & Arakawa, C. (2010). Inter-comparison of the meso scale meteorological models for wind power prediction. Journal of Wind Engineering, 35(1), 17-26.

Lee M, Lee SH, Hur N, Choi CK. A numerical simulation of flow field in a wind farm on complex terrain. Wind and Structures 2010; 13(4):375.

Moreno P, Gravdahl AR, Romero M. Wind flow over complex terrain: application of linear and cfd models. European wind energy conference and exhibition, 2003; 16–19.

Castellani F., Astolfi D., Burlando M., Terzi L.: Numerical modelling for wind farm operational assessment in complex terrain. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, 147: 320-329. (2015)

Peralta C, Nugusse H, Kokilavani S, Schmidt J, Stoevesandt B. Validation of the simplefoam (rans) solver for the atmospheric boundary layer in complex terrain. ITM Web of Conferences, vol. 2, EDP Sciences, 2014; 01 002.

Bechmann A, Sørensen NN, Berg J, Mann J, Re ́thore ́ PE. The bolund experiment, part ii: blind comparison of microscale flow models. Boundary-Layer Meteorology 2011; 141(2):245–271.

Rodrigo JS, Gancarski P, Arroyo RC, Moriarty P, Chuchfield M, Naughton JW, Hansen KS, Machefaux E, Koblitz T, Maguire E, et al.. Iea-task 31 wakebench: Towards a protocol for wind farm flow model evaluation. part 1: Flow- over-terrain models. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, vol. 524, IOP Publishing, 2014; 012 105.

Schulz C., Klein L., Weihing P., Lutz T. Investigations into the interaction of a wind turbine with atmospheric turbulence in complex terrain. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, vol. 753, IOP Publishing, 2016; 032 016.

Subramanian B, Chokani N, Abhari R. Aerodynamics of wind turbine wakes in flat and complex terrains. Renewable Energy 2016; 85:454–463.

Castellani F., Astolfi D., Piccioni E., Terzi L.: Numerical and experimental methods for wake flow analysis in complex terrain. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 625. IOP Publishing (2015)

Castellani F., Astolfi D., Garinei A., Proietti S., Sdringola P., Terzi L, Desideri U.: How wind turbines alignment to wind direction affects efficiency? A case study through SCADA data mining. Energy Procedia 75: 697-703 (2015)

Castellani F., Astolfi D., Sdringola P., Proietti S., Terzi L.: Analyzing wind turbine directional behavior: SCADA data mining techniques for efficiency and power assessment. Volume 185, Part 2, 1 January 2017, Pages 1076–1086

Hyvärinen, A., & Segalini, A. (2017). Effects from complex terrain on wind-turbine performance. Journal of Energy Resources Technology.

Castellani, F., Astolfi, D., Mana, M., Piccioni, E., Bec- chetti, M., and Terzi, L., 2017. “Investigation of ter- rain and wake effects on the performance of wind farms in complex terrain using numerical and experimental data”. Wind Energy, 20, pp. 1277–1289.

Moriarty, P., Rodrigo, J. S., Gancarski, P., Chuchfield, M., Naughton, J. W., Hansen, K. S., ... & Breton, S. P. (2014). IEA-Task 31 WAKEBENCH: Towards a protocol for wind farm flow model evaluation. Part 2: Wind farm wake models. In Journal of Physics: Conference Series (Vol. 524, No. 1, p. 012185). IOP Publishing.

A Tascikaraoglu and M Uzunoglu. A review of combined approaches for prediction of short-term wind speed and power. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 34:243–254, 2014.

Foley, A.M., Leahy, P.G., Marvuglia, A., McKeogh, E.J. Current methods and advances in forecasting of wind power generation. (2012) Renewable Energy, 37 (1), pp. 1-8.

Stefano Alessandrini, Pierre Pinson, Renate Hagedorn, G Decimi, and S Sperati. An application of ensemble/multi model approach for wind power production forecasting. Advances in Science and Research, 6(1):35–37, 2011.

Jain, V., Singh, A., Chauhan, V., Pandey, A. Analytical study of Wind power prediction system by using Feed Forward Neural Network (2016) 2016 International Conference on Computation of Power, Energy, Information and Communication, ICCPEIC 2016, art. no. 7557247, pp. 303-306.

Deepa Lakshmi, B., Sujatha, K. Artificial neural networks for wind speed prediction (2016) International Journal of Control Theory and Applications, 9 (4), pp. 1953-1959.

Aval, S.M.M., Ahadi, A. Wind turbine fault diagnosis techniques and related algorithms (2016) International Journal of Renewable Energy Research, 6 (1), pp. 80-89.

Wenxian Yang, Richard Court, Jieshen Jiang. Wind turbine condition monitoring by the approach of SCADA data analysis. Renewable Energy 53: 365-376. 2013

Bartolini, N., Scappaticci, L., Garinei, A., Becchetti, M., Terzi, L. Analysing wind turbine state dynamics for fault diagnosis (2016) Diagnostyka, 17 (4), pp. 19-25.

Godwin, J.L., Matthews, P. Classification and detection of wind turbine pitch faults through SCADA data analysis (2013) International Journal of Prognostics and Health Management, 4

Astolfi D, Castellani F., Terzi L.: Fault prevention and diagnosis through SCADA temperature data analysis of an onshore wind farm. Diagnostyka, 15. (2014)

Castellani F., Garinei A., Terzi L., Astolfi D., Moretti M., Lombardi A.: A new data mining approach for power performance verification of an on-shore wind farm. Diagnostyka 14 (2013)

Astolfi D., Castellani F., Scappaticci L., Terzi L. Diagnosis of wind turbine misalignment through SCADA data. Diagnostyka 2017, Vol 18(1):19-26

Cao, Mengnan, et al. "Study of Wind Turbine Fault Diagnosis Based on Unscented Kalman Filter and SCADA Data." Energies 9.10 (2016): 847.

Leahy, Kevin, et al. "Diagnosing wind turbine faults using machine learning techniques applied to operational data." Prognostics and Health Management (ICPHM), 2016 IEEE International Conference on. IEEE, 2016.

Astolfi, D., Scappaticci, L., & Terzi, L. (2017). Fault Diagnosis of Wind Turbine Gearboxes Through Temperature and Vibration Data. International Journal of Renewable Energy Research (IJRER), 7(2), 965-976

Herp, J., Pedersen, N.L., Nadimi, E.S. Wind turbine performance analysis based on multivariate higher order moments and Bayesian classifiers (2016) Control Engineering Practice, 49, pp. 204-211.

Lapira, E., Brisset, D., Davari Ardakani, H., Siegel, D., Lee, J. Wind turbine performance assessment using multi-regime modeling approach (2012) Renewable Energy, 45, pp. 86-95.

Astolfi D., Castellani F., Garinei A., Terzi L.: Data mining techniques for performance analysis of onshore wind farms. Applied Energy 148: 220–233. (2015)

Castellani F., Astolfi D., Terzi L., Hansen K.S., Rodrigo J.S.: Analysing wind farm efficiency on complex terrains. Journal of Physics: Conference Series 524, 1.

Astolfi D., Castellani F., Terzi L.: Mathematical methods for SCADA data mining of onshore wind farms: Performance evaluation and wake analysis. Wind Engineering 40 (1): 69-85. SAGE Publications. (2016)

Castellani F., Garinei A., Terzi L., Astolfi D., Gaudiosi M.: Improving windfarm operation practice through numerical modelling and supervisory control and data acquisition data analysis. Renewable Power Generation, IET 8 (4) (2014) 367-379

Jia, Xiaodong, et al. "Wind turbine performance degradation assessment based on a novel similarity metric for machine performance curves." Renewable Energy 99 (2016): 1191-1201.

Dai, Juchuan, et al. "Ageing assessment of a wind turbine over time by interpreting wind farm SCADA data." Renewable Energy (2017).

Scappaticci, L., Bartolini, N., Garinei, A., Becchetti, M., & Terzi, L. (2017). Analysing Wind Turbine States and SCADA Data for Fault Diagnosis. International Journal of Renewable Energy Research (IJRER), 7(1), 323-329.

Castellani, F., Garinei, A., Terzi, L., Astolfi, D. Applied statistics for extreme wind estimate (2015) Wind Energy, 18 (4), pp. 613-624.

Castellani, F., D'Elia, G., Astolfi, D., Mucchi, E., Giorgio, D., Terzi, L. Analyzing wind turbine flow interaction through vibration data (2016) Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 753 (11)

Kavousi-Fard, A., Khosravi, A., Nahavandi, S. A new fuzzy-based combined prediction interval for wind power forecasting (2016) IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 31 (1), art. no. 7035120, pp. 18-26

Ozkan, M.B., Karagoz, P. A novel wind power forecast model: Statistical hybrid wind power forecast technique (SHWIP) (2015) IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, 11 (2), art. no. 7018961, pp. 375-387.

Heinermann, J., & Kramer, O. (2016). Machine learning ensembles for wind power prediction. Renewable Energy, 89, 671-679.

Chang, Gary W., et al. "Gaussian mixture model‐based neural network for short‐term wind power forecast." International Transactions on Electrical Energy Systems (2017).

Aguilar, S., Souza, R. C., & Pensanha, J. F. (2014, October). Predicting probabilistic wind power generation using nonparametric techniques. In Renewable Energy Research and Application (ICRERA), 2014 International Conference on (pp. 709-712). IEEE.

Paramasivan, S. K., & Lopez, D. (2016). Forecasting of wind speed using feature selection and neural networks. International Journal of Renewable Energy Research (IJRER), 6(3), 833-837.

Lahouar, A., and J. Ben Hadj Slama. "Hour-ahead wind power forecast based on random forests." Renewable Energy (2017).

Chang, G. W., et al. "An improved neural network-based approach for short-term wind speed and power forecast." Renewable Energy 105 (2017): 301-311.

Kaur, Tarlochan, Sanjay Kumar, and Ravi Segal. "Application of artificial neural network for short term wind speed forecasting." Power and Energy Systems: Towards Sustainable Energy (PESTSE), 2016 Biennial International Conference on. IEEE, 2016.

Heydari, Azim, and Farshid Keynia. "Prediction of wind power generation through combining particle swarm optimization and elman neural network (El-PSO)." International Energy Journal 15.2 (2016).

Dong, Qingli, Yuhuan Sun, and Peizhi Li. "A novel forecasting model based on a hybrid processing strategy and an optimized local linear fuzzy neural network to make wind power forecasting: A case study of wind farms in China." Renewable Energy 102 (2017): 241-257

Zhang, Yachao, et al. "Deterministic and probabilistic interval prediction for short-term wind power generation based on variational mode decomposition and machine learning methods." Energy Conversion and Management 112 (2016): 208-219.

Huang, Nantian, et al. "Hybrid Short Term Wind Speed Forecasting Using Variational Mode Decomposition and a Weighted Regularized Extreme Learning Machine." Energies 9.12 (2016): 989.

Dowell, Jethro, and Pierre Pinson. "Very-short-term probabilistic wind power forecasts by sparse vector autoregression." IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid 7.2 (2016): 763-770.

Iversen, Emil B., et al. "Leveraging stochastic differential equations for probabilistic forecasting of wind power using a dynamic power curve." Wind Energy 20.1 (2017): 33-44.

Yang, Mao, and QiongQiong Yang. "Wind power forecast based on cloud model." Probabilistic Methods Applied to Power Systems (PMAPS), 2016 International Conference on. IEEE, 2016.

Miettinen, Jari Johannes, and Hannele Holttinen. "Characteristics of day‐ahead wind power forecast errors in Nordic countries and benefits of aggregation." Wind Energy (2016).

Ye, Yida, et al. "Conditional probabilistic modeling of wind power forecast error." Power and Energy Society General Meeting (PESGM), 2016. IEEE, 2016.

Wei, Peng, Qian Zhou, and Jiankun Liu. "Modeling Wind Power Forecasting Error Using Piecewise Exponential Distribution." DEStech Transactions on Engineering and Technology Research iceta (2016).

Wu, Y.-K., Su, P.-E., Hong, J.-S. An overview of wind power probabilistic forecasts (2016) Asia-Pacific Power and Energy Engineering Conference, APPEEC, 2016-December, art. no. 7779540, pp. 429-433.

Ata, R. (2015). Artificial neural networks applications in wind energy systems: a review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 49, 534-562.

Jung, Jaesung, and Robert P. Broadwater. "Current status and future advances for wind speed and power forecasting." Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 31 (2014): 762-777.

Mao, Yang, and Wang Shaoshuai. "A review of wind power forecasting & prediction." Probabilistic Methods Applied to Power Systems (PMAPS), 2016 International Conference on. IEEE, 2016.

Yan, Jie, et al. "Reviews on uncertainty analysis of wind power forecasting." Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 52 (2015): 1322-1330.

Castellani, F., Burlando, M., Taghizadeh, S., Astolfi, D., & Piccioni, E. (2014). Wind energy forecast in complex sites with a 3 neural network and CFD based method. Energy Procedia, 45, 188-197.

Castellani, F., Astolfi, D., Mana, M., Burlando, M., Meißner, C., & Piccioni, E. (2016, September). Wind power forecasting techniques in complex terrain: ANN vs. ANN-CFD hybrid approach. In Journal of Physics: Conference Series (Vol. 753, No. 8, p. 082002). IOP Publishing.

Li, Li, et al. "A physical approach of the short-term wind power prediction based on CFD pre-calculated flow fields." Journal of Hydrodynamics, Ser. B 25.1 (2013): 56-61.

Li, Li, Yi-mei Wang, and Yong-qian Liu. "Impact of wake effect on wind power prediction." Renewable Power Generation Conference (RPG 2013), 2nd IET. IET, 2013

Efe, B., Mentes, S., Unal, Y., Tan, E., Unal, E., Ozdemir, T., ... & Topcu, S. (2012, November). 72hr forecast of wind power in Manisa, Turkey by using the WRF model coupled to WindSim. In Renewable energy research and applications (ICRERA), 2012 international conference on (pp. 1-6). IEEE.

Evangelos S Politis, John Prospathopoulos, D Cabezon, Kurt S Hansen, PK Chaviaropoulos, and Rebecca J Barthelmie. Modeling wake effects in large wind farms in complex terrain: the problem, the methods and the issues. Wind Energy, 15(1):161–182, 2012.

Ann Hyva ̈rinen and Antonio Segalini. Effects from complex terrain on wind-turbine performance. Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 2017.

Avinaash Murali and RG Rajagopalan. Numerical simulation of multiple interacting wind turbines on a complex terrain. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, 162:57–72, 2017.

Fredrik Seim, Arne R Gravdahl, and Muyiwa S Adaramola. Validation of kinematic wind turbine wake models in complex terrain using actual windfarm production data. Energy, 123:742–753, 2017.

Skamarock, W. C., Klemp, J. B., Dudhia, J., Gill, D. O., Barker, D. M., Wang, W., & Powers, J. G. (2005). A description of the advanced research WRF version 2 (No. NCAR/TN-468+ STR). National Center For Atmospheric Research Boulder Co Mesoscale and Microscale Meteorology Div.

Jensen, N. O. (1983). A note on wind generator interaction.

Gravdahl, A. R., & Harstveit, K. (2000). WindSim–Flow simulations in complex terrain, Assessment of wind resources along the Norwegian coast. In 5th German Wind Energy Conference.

Klisić, Đ., Zlatanović, M., & Radovanović, I. (2011). Windsim® computational flow dynamics model testing using databases from two wind measurement stations. Electronics, 15(2), 43-48.

Castellani, F., Vignaroli, A., Gravdahl, A.R. Wind simulation on complex terrain: About the dependencies on inlet flow orthogonality (2006) European Wind Energy Conference and Exhibition 2006, EWEC 2006, 2, pp. 1381-1386.

Dhunny, A.Z., Lollchund, M.R., Rughooputh, S.D.D.V. Wind energy evaluation for a highly complex terrain using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) (2017) Renewable Energy, 101, pp. 1-9.

Cornejo-Bueno, L., Camacho-Gómez, C., Aybar-Ruiz, A., Prieto, L., & Salcedo-Sanz, S. (2016, September). Feature Selection with a Grouping Genetic Algorithm–Extreme Learning Machine Approach for Wind Power Prediction. In Conference of the Spanish Association for Artificial Intelligence (pp. 373-382). Springer International Publishing

Hong, D. Y., et al. "An indirect short-term wind power forecast approach with multi-variable inputs." Innovative Smart Grid Technologies-Asia (ISGT-Asia), 2016 IEEE. IEEE, 2016.

de Andrade Vieira, R. J., & Sanz-Bobi, M. A. (2015, November). Power curve modelling of a wind turbine for monitoring its behaviour. In Renewable Energy Research and Applications (ICRERA), 2015 International Conference on (pp. 1052-1057). IEEE.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Online ISSN: 1309-0127


ijrereditor@gmail.com; ilhcol@gmail.com;

IJRER is cited in SCOPUS, EBSCO, WEB of SCIENCE (Thomson Reuters)